Britney Spears Drops Previously Unreleased Pop Banger ‘She’ll Never Be Me,’ Co-Written With Then-Boyfriend Justin Timberlake: Listen

Britney Spears is effectively retired from pop music, but next month, her fans will get to hear a previously unreleased track that is likely to spark serious early 2000s nostalgia. On Friday (Oct. 9), the 44-year-old singer dropped “She’ll Never Be Me,” a classic-era Britney pop banger that was originally recorded for her self-titled third LP, 2001’s Britney.

Spears co-wrote the song with her then-boyfriend, Justin Timberlake, as well as Bradley Daymond (*NSYNC) and Alex Greggs (*NSYNC, Paris Hilton) and it was co-produced by Riprock ‘n’ Alex G.

“You know I’m one of a kind/ Boy, what’s this I see/ Your girl, she looks just like me/ Blond hair and dressed to a T/ You tell me how can this be/ Does she know I was the one/ Who used to turn you on,” Spears sings in her signature nasally, girlish voice over a burping keyboards and a robotic, drum machine beat.

The song is among a bevy of previously unreleased tracks slated to appear on the upcoming 25th anniversary edition of Britney, due out on Nov. 6. In addition to such beloved hits as “I’m a Slave 4 U,” “Overprotected,” “Lonely” and “I’m Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman,” the 25-song expanded version will feature the “I’m a Slave 4 U” B-side “Intimidated,” as well as “Right Now (Taste the Victory),” from the singer’s 2002 Pepsi commercial, and the previously unreleased songs “Am I a Sinner,” “When I Say So” and “My Big Secret,” produced by the Neptunes, according to the singer’s posted tracklist.

“You know I’m one of a kind/ There’ll never be another me/ Can’t get me out of your mind/ You’re lost in your own fantasy/ And when you look in my eyes/ Is it hard for you to realize/ She’ll never be me,” Spears sings on the kiss-off chorus of the song in which she slams an ex for replacing her with an exact replica.

Britney signaled a more grown-up direction for the then-19-year-old singer, following on the heels of her breakout LPs …Baby One More Time and Oops!… I Did It Again. The album also featured another Timberlake collaboration, the JT co-written/co-produced “What It’s Like to Be Me,” which closed out the original set. Spears and Timberlake began dating in 1999 and broke up in March 2002. After their split, Timberlake released the revenge tune “Cry Me a River,” whose video featured a Spears look-alike to go with lyrics about a man who refuses to take back his ex after discovering that she’s been unfaithful.

Spears has not yet posted about the song on her socials, though her Facebook account teased on Sept. 30 that “more surprises are coming every week” until the refreshed album’s November release.

The JT co-write is the first “new” music from Spears since she teamed up with will.i.am on 2023’s “Mind Your Business” and Elton John on “Hold Me Closer” in 2022.

In January of this year, Spears — who hasn’t released an album of new material since 2016’s Glory — vowed that she would “never perform in the U.S. again,” more than seven years after wrapping her global Piece of Me tour. Her most recent live performance was on Oct. 21, 2018 in Austin, Texas and the singer adamantly stated in 2024 that she will “never return to the music industry.”

Listen to “She’ll Never Be Me” below.