TRENDING
Suno Says Jason Isbell Lawsuit Over Artist ‘Identities’ Must Be Dismissed: ‘Nothing Unlawful About That’
Published
1 week agoon
By
Bill Donahue
Suno is asking a judge to throw out a lawsuit claiming the AI music firm stole the artistic identities of Jason Isbell and other stars, arguing there’s “nothing unlawful” about seeking to replicate the “vibe” of a particular artist.
Isbell sued in August, accusing Suno of allowing users to “conjure up a beloved musician’s identity” by entering their name as a prompt in its AI song generator. It was a novel case centered on an artist’s likeness rights, unlike earlier litigation against AI labs over the use of copyrighted music to train models.
Related
Jason Isbell Files Class Action Lawsuit Claiming Suno Coded AI to ‘Extract Musicians’ Identities’
Kenny MacPherson, Veteran Music Publisher and Big Deal Music Co-Founder, Dies at 71
Diddy Moved From New Jersey Prison to Similar Facility in Pennsylvania
But in Suno’s first major response on Tuesday (Nov. 3), its lawyers say there is “nothing unlawful” about merely using an artist’s name to describe music, any more than it’s illegal for a human artist to say “let’s go for something here with more of a Jason Isbell vibe.”
“When people describe styles of music, they often use artists’ names as shorthand for the genre they perform in,” Suno’s lawyers write in a motion obtained and first reported by Billboard. “This case turns on the premise that the law somehow condemns that universal practice. In reality it does not; the First Amendment would not allow it to.”
Suno’s motion, which asks the judge to dismiss the case immediately, argues that Isbell’s lawsuit attacks “ubiquitous methods of communicating ideas” and would hurt the “creative and cultural ecosystem” if allowed to proceed.
An attorney for Isbell did not immediately return a request for comment on Tuesday.
Isbell and other artists sued in August, accusing Suno of violating artists’ likeness rights (also known as publicity rights) by encoding their entire musical personas as tokens in its AI model. The case was filed as a class action, seeking to potentially represent “millions” of other artists: “The platform is built to identify musicians by name and generate identity-evocative output on command. This is its product.”
Related
UMG & Sony Hit Suno With New Lawsuit After Label-Backed Model: ‘Fruit of the Same Poisoned Tree’
Suno was already facing a slew of lawsuits from major music companies, who claim the company violated their federal copyrights by ingesting millions of songs to train their models. The new case was different, accusing Suno of breaching state laws in New York, California, Tennessee and elsewhere that protect a person’s name, image and likeness from commercial exploitation.
Suno says it doesn’t actually allow users to prompt its AI model with specific artist names. When users do enter artist names, the platform says it translates that request into “descriptive musical characteristics,” which can then be used to direct the model to generate a song. A prompt of “Duran Duran,” for example, might get redirected into one of “New wave, Synth-pop, Pop rock.”
Isbell’s lawsuit claims those safeguards are faulty and can be duped by merely using spaces, such as Taylor Swift with “t a y l o r s w i f t” or Bad Bunny with “b a d b u n n y.” Even when a name is translated into musical styles, Isbell says the model clearly still exploits an artist’s identity: “Suno built and trained a model to index musicians by name. It encoded musicians’ identities into its AI model to create its commercial product without consent.”
But in Tuesday’s response, Suno says those accusations are legally deeply flawed. Simply using the name of a real person as a “shorthand to convey information about the genre that they want to create in,” Suno’s attorneys argue, is not the kind of thing that has historically violated state-law likeness rights.
“The law does not prevent people from using names to find or describe information, nor does it prevent building a tool capable of recognizing those references and acting on the information they supply,” Suno’s lawyers write, arguing that a ruling to the contrary would violate the First Amendment’s freedom of speech.
Even if likeness rights worked that way, Suno says the case would still be doomed by federal “preemption,” a legal doctrine that bars state-level claims that interfere with existing federal laws. Allowing artists to sue to assert their state-level likeness rights in such a way, Suno says, would overlap too much with federal copyright law’s existing protections for creative works.
“Congress made the considered policy choice not to confer intellectual property protection on an artistic style, precisely to allow subsequent creators to build on the prior works of a genre,” Suno says. “[This lawsuit] would create a shadow state law IP regime … fundamentally conflicting with the federal regime that has been in place for more than two centuries.”
Bill Donahue
You may like
-
Executive Turntable: Drew Wilson Named PRG CFO, TuneCore Elevates Tash Shah
-
Travis Barker Reveals He Stopped Smoking Weed After Precancer Diagnosis: ‘I Loved Blunts’
-
Takeoff Estate Resolves Lawsuit Over Alleged 2020 Sexual Assault
-
Could Jason & Travis Kelce Judge ‘DWTS’? Taylor Swift’s Backup Dancer Thinks It’d Be ‘Incredible’
-
Pitbull Shares the Stories Behind ‘On the Floor,’ ‘Feel This Moment’ & More | Chart History
-
LNGSHOT Talk Musical Attitude & Group’s Turning Point: ‘S.W.I.S.H.’
Executive Turntable: Drew Wilson Named PRG CFO, TuneCore Elevates Tash Shah
Queen Latifah’s Full-Circle Moment: How the Rock Hall Honoree Is Giving Back to New Jersey
Travis Barker Reveals He Stopped Smoking Weed After Precancer Diagnosis: ‘I Loved Blunts’
‘Slick, Cheeky, Playful And a Little Provocative’: VASSY Serves Up ‘Dirty Martini’
Lisa’s ‘Viva La Lisa’ Las Vegas Residency Setlist: Every Song From Night 1
Killa Bone Brings Southern Influence to the Indianapolis Rap Scene
Yulia Lundy Is Turning Dreams Into Reality
T Staggs Talks Southern Soul Era, Vol. 2 and Turning Real Life Into Music
Exclusive Interview With Killa Bone
Exclusive Interview With Positive Society
146Big Bank “Run The Trap” Shot By @BillMikeProductions
Demons Cutting Me
Sosseé – Jack In The Box
X.irda • Slim Spitta – MASQUERADE (Official music video)
Lil Noonie – Not Me (Official Music Video)
TRENDING
Executive Turntable: Drew Wilson Named PRG CFO, TuneCore Elevates Tash Shah
Production Resource Group has named Drew Wilson chief financial officer. Wilson joins from SoundCloud, where he served as chief operating...
Queen Latifah’s Full-Circle Moment: How the Rock Hall Honoree Is Giving Back to New Jersey
“First of all, let me teach you how to walk through Newark. Don’t say ‘New-work,’” quips Queen Latifah, playfully schooling...
Travis Barker Reveals He Stopped Smoking Weed After Precancer Diagnosis: ‘I Loved Blunts’
Travis Barker had a very good reason for giving up weed. During a sit-down with Kid Cudi on this week’s...
‘Slick, Cheeky, Playful And a Little Provocative’: VASSY Serves Up ‘Dirty Martini’
Hits, history, kids, and Tomorrowland. If the year 2026 has been a blur for VASSY, that’s entirely fair. The U.S.-based...
Lisa’s ‘Viva La Lisa’ Las Vegas Residency Setlist: Every Song From Night 1
Lisa wrote a new chapter in her career Thursday night (Nov. 12), becoming the first K-pop artist to headline a...



