Nick Cave Clarifies ‘Uncharitable’ Red Hot Chili Peppers Comments: ‘There Was No Malice Intended’

Nick Cave has responded to the viral comments he once made about the Red Hot Chili Peppers, clarifying his current stance on the band in the process.

Cave’s comments about the Los Angeles funk-rockers have circulated as something of a punchline for roughly 25 years now. Though their exact origins appear to have been lost to time, the quote is often attributed to Cave as, “I’m forever near a stereo saying, ‘What the fuck is this garbage?’ And the answer is always ‘The Red Hot Chili Peppers.’”

Chili Peppers bassist Flea (who, like Cave, was born in the Australian state of Victoria) responded to Cave’s scathing remark in 2006, noting that it initially hurt his feelings since he’s a huge fan of the Bad Seeds frontman. 

“I don’t care if Nick Cave hates my band because his music means everything to me,” Flea said. “He is one of my favorite songwriters and singers and musicians of all time. I love all the incarnations of the Bad Seeds. But it only hurt my feelings for a second because my love for his music is bigger than all that shit and if he thinks my band is lame then that’s OK.”

Now, Cave has taken to his Red Hand Files website to respond to a fan asking about the truthfulness of the quote, referring to his comments as an “offhand and somewhat uncharitable remark” about the band. 

“There was no malice intended, it was just the sort of obnoxious thing I would say back then to piss people off,” Cave explained. “I was a troublemaker, a shit-stirrer, feeling most at ease in the role of a societal irritant. Perhaps it’s an Australian trait among people of my generation, I don’t know, but that comment has followed me around for the last quarter-century.”

Cave also recalled how Flea’s own response had made its way to him, moving him and bringing forth the realization that “Flea was a human being of an entirely different calibre, indeed, of a higher order.” He also added that the pair have since apparently patched things up, with “pleasant” interactions following both on and off the stage in different iterations over the years.

The response closed with the revelation that Flea is apparently in the process of crafting a new album, with Cave noting he recently added his vocals to the new record which sees Flea’s trumpet-playing skills on full display.

“Last week, Flea sent me a song and asked if I’d like to add some vocals. It was for a ‘trumpet record’ that he is making,” Cave explained. “It is not for me to divulge what the song was, only that it is a song I cherish more than most, with arguably the greatest lyric ever written, a song of such esteem that I would never have dared to sing it had Flea not asked me to. I went into the studio on Wednesday and recorded my vocals. 

“The track emerged as a beautiful conversation between Flea’s trumpet and my voice, filled with yearning and love, the song transcending its individual parts and becoming a slowly evolving cosmic dance, in the form of a reconciliation and an apology.”